Baking Spices

In the simplest terms, baking spices are the spices generally used in baking. But with all the different cultures and cuisines with their unique recipes, the term has come to refer to different things to different people based on what they associate with their favorite bread and cookies.

Still, a few specific spices bring to mind the warmth of the oven and a freshly baked batch of cookies or a loaf of bread you may have come across at the baker’s. These are counted as ‘baking spices’. For obvious reasons, these are often associated with Christmas.

Spices and Condiments Associated With Baking

It includes all the typical spices, including a couple of seeds, with an idea of what they taste like in baked goodies.

Additionally, you can get some ideas for substitutions and alterations if a particular spice is not at hand. But remember, no substitute will smell and taste identical to the original spice because each has its unique aroma and taste. Also, adjust the quantities based on your use and the recipe.

Name	Flavor Profile	Used For	Substitutes & Alternatives
Cinnamon	Warm, sweet, and slightly spicy	Cakes, cookies, pies	Allspice, nutmeg
Star Anise	Licorice-like, sweet, and aromatic	Breads, cookies	Anise seeds, fennel seeds
Ginger	Warm, spicy, and slightly sweet	Gingerbread, cookies	Ground allspice, cinnamon
Nutmeg	Warm, nutty, and slightly sweet	Cakes, pies, custards	Cinnamon, allspice
Allspice	Aromatic, warm, and slightly sweet	Cakes, pies, cookies	Cinnamon, nutmeg
Vanilla Extract	Sweet, rich, and aromatic	Cakes, cookies	Whole vanilla beans, almond extract
Anise Seed	Strong, licorice-like	Breads, cookies	Star anise, fennel seeds
Cardamom	Citrusy, spicy, and slightly sweet	Breads, cakes	Cinnamon, ginger
Cloves	Pungent, warm, and sweet	Pies, cookies	Allspice, cinnamon
Mace	Warm and nutmeg-like	Cakes, cookies	Nutmeg, allspice
Poppy Seed	Mild, nutty, and slightly sweet	Breads, muffins	Sesame, chia seeds
Sesame Seed	Nutty and slightly earthy	Breads, cookies	Poppy, flax, sunflower seeds
Coriander	Citrusy, slightly sweet, and earthy	Breads, cookies	Cumin, cardamom
Fennel Seed	Sweet and licorice-like	Breads, cookies	Anise seeds, star anise

Almost all these spices are best when added ground in baked items, though a few of them, like clove and cardamom, may also be used whole. The seeds are also often used whole or lightly crushed.

The very last entries, coriander and fennel, may be considered somewhat unusual by many. However, they can be as good as any of the other spices. Ground coriander works well in deepening the flavors of cookies while adding a citrusy brightness. Fennel can be used much the same as anise seeds.

FAQ